their
This post is similar to the 'a lot' post in that i'm arguing for breaking a grammar rule in the English language in order to make it more user-friendly. In this case, I feel that a writer should be able to substitute the word 'their' for 'his/her' because it looks better and is faster to type. Saying and writing his/her all the time, in my opinion, weakens the writing and distracts from the point.
Now, understand that I'm only refering to a very specific case here. It usually occurs when one is trying to say "A person should such and such and such..." and then one needs a possesive pronoun. You can't just say 'his' because then your politically incorret, so you either have to say 'his/her', or break the grammatical rules and go with 'their'. It also makes sense in the sense that one is usually refering to 'a person' in the sense of one out of many (e pluribus unum) so there is a connotation of it being plural.
For those who would insist that a plural matches up with a plural, I would point out one glaring example of an instance where we always match a plural with a singular. Are is quite clearly a plural verb, we use it for 'we', 'they', 'many,' etc. But we also use it for 'you', which is equally clearly a singular pronoun. You are only one person. Thus, from the point of view of grammatical consistancy, "you is," is more correct than "you are,". I'm not suggesting we change 'you are', I'm just suggesting we let me use 'their' instead of 'his/her'.
Now, understand that I'm only refering to a very specific case here. It usually occurs when one is trying to say "A person should such and such and such..." and then one needs a possesive pronoun. You can't just say 'his' because then your politically incorret, so you either have to say 'his/her', or break the grammatical rules and go with 'their'. It also makes sense in the sense that one is usually refering to 'a person' in the sense of one out of many (e pluribus unum) so there is a connotation of it being plural.
For those who would insist that a plural matches up with a plural, I would point out one glaring example of an instance where we always match a plural with a singular. Are is quite clearly a plural verb, we use it for 'we', 'they', 'many,' etc. But we also use it for 'you', which is equally clearly a singular pronoun. You are only one person. Thus, from the point of view of grammatical consistancy, "you is," is more correct than "you are,". I'm not suggesting we change 'you are', I'm just suggesting we let me use 'their' instead of 'his/her'.
